It’s Not About Us!

During Inauguration weekend, I had a conversation with the pastor of a Presbyterian Church that was predominately black church.  When asked if the members of that church would be participating in the Women’s March the reply was “That is not a black issue”.  This was not a comment dismissing the issues which brought those marchers together.  Rather this pastor was reminding us that racial prejudice and injustice have not been eradicated.  And the worry is that the energy around this Women’s March would not detract from important efforts to combat racism.

One of the scripture texts from the Lectionary recently was Matthew 5:1-12 better known as the Beatitudes.  This is a scripture we have read from the same translation for so long that we often read the words as relating to others.  Blessed are those….  (others who are poor, persecuted and more).   Reading this passage in The Message, translated by Eugene Peterson gives us a very different perspective on Jesus’ words.  “You are blessed when you are at the end of your rope. With less of you there is more of God and God’s rule” v3.  This reminds me of the anonymous poster saying “Where were you God when I was walking alone?”  “ Beside you.”  “Where were you when I could not walk any further?”  “Carrying you.”

In these transition times in our country and around the world we are challenged more forcefully to remember that we, our communities of faith, our communities and our country are our responsibility to live into out of our Christian faith, our partnership with God.  We cannot be passive and comfortable expecting God to rescue someone else.  We cannot be violent.  We are charged to speak to injustice and unfairness out of our faith.

Our complaints, protest and hand wringing should not be about the slights we feel individually.  Instead we are called to share the message that God calls us to love and care for all of creation. On further reflection, we can see that when our oppressors segment our particular complaints we are weaker.  Justice for all is the goal – this includes racial justice, ending faith based prejudice, marriage equality, gender equality, eco justice and many more.   The US is formed into “One nation under God, indivisible with liberty and justice for all”.  Not just justice for my particular injustice.

Reading Eugene Peterson again:  “You’re blessed when you show people how to cooperate instead of compete or fight.  That’s when you discover who you really are and your place in God’s family.  You’re blessed when your commitment to God provokes persecution.  The persecution drives you even deeper into God’s Kingdom.  Not only that – count yourselves blessed every time people put you down or throw you out or speak lies about you to discredit me.  What it means is that the truth is too close for comfort and they are uncomfortable.” Matt 5:10-11.

It’s not about us!   It is about bringing God’s justice to the world around us.

Rev. Peter Surgenor is the Executive Director of Holmes Presbyterian Camp and Conference Center, a parish associate at the Bedford Presbyterian Church and moderator of Hudson River Presbytery in 2017.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

What Does The Lord Require of Me?

Micah: 6:8 – He has told you, O mortal, what is good; and what does the Lord require of you but to do justice, and to love kindness, and to walk humbly with your God?

This week’s lectionary, the schedule of scripture passages for the day, included the passage from Micah, above. I love that passage. I think about what it means to “do justice,” “to love kindness,” and “to walk humbly” with my God. Humility seems in very short supply today. As does “justice” and “kindness,” for that matter.

Thomas Merton could be talking about right now, even though he wrote these words in the 1960’s in New Seeds of Contemplation:

“We never see the one truth that would help us begin to solve our ethical and political problems: that we are all more or less wrong, that we are all at fault, all limited and obstructed by our mixed motives, our self-deception, our greed, our self-righteousness and our tendency to aggression and hypocrisy.”

Now there’s a definition of humility! And so I’ve been trying to remember that I am more or less wrong and certainly at fault, when I decide (even if I do it subconsciously) that if you aren’t with me you are against me. Pema Chodron, the Buddhist nun, reminds us that “All the wars, all the hatred, all the ignorance in the world come out of being so invested in our opinions.”

But how to bridge that divide? Perhaps if I try to remember that most people are doing the best that they can, that they probably have very good reasons to see things exactly opposite from the way that I do. Perhaps I can try to remember that the people “on the other side” have probably made up their minds about me, too.

And so I pray the peace prayer of Saint Francis:

Lord, make me an instrument of your peace:
where there is hatred, let me sow love;
where there is injury, pardon;
where there is doubt, faith;
where there is despair, hope;
where there is darkness, light;
where there is sadness, joy.

O divine Master, grant that I may not so much seek
to be consoled as to console,
to be understood as to understand,
to be loved as to love.
For it is in giving that we receive,
it is in pardoning that we are pardoned,
and it is in dying that we are born to eternal life.

May we act justly, love mercy and walk humbly, and may God grant us peace. Amen.

Connie Knapp is a Ruling Elder at First Presbyterian Church in Yorktown and a participant in the Commissioned Ruling Elders program of the Hudson River Presbytery.


Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment

Finding My Way…


inauguration  womens-march

I am sitting at my desk today feeling buffeted by Friday’s inauguration and Saturday’s marches.  Opposing words, opposing visions, opposing passions.  I am aware that, while I have a clear preference, my reality does not align completely with any of these.

I am drawn to memories of a bible study group I helped lead at Bedford Hills Correctional Facility a week or two ago.  We watched a video clip on “God” from the (excellent!) DVD, Animate Faith.  In the clip, the speaker introduced the concepts of the kataphatic and apophatic traditions, unfamiliar words for this group.  In the kataphatic tradition, words used to describe God have real meaning.  When we say God is like a rock, or a shield, or living water, or fire, or a father, or a king, those words have some accuracy or meaning in describing God.  In the apophatic tradition, words are useless in describing God.  In this tradition, for any word used to describe God, its opposite is also true.  So, while God is the Lord of Hosts, or Armies, God, in the person of Jesus is also humble, a sacrificial lamb, and the one who pours himself out on our behalf.  The strong, immovable “rock” God is also a fluid, changeable “water” or “fire” God.  The “forgiving and merciful” God is also a “judging and avenging” God.  In the apophatic tradition, our contemplation of God reduces us to an awed silence and the acknowledgement that God is completely beyond our human language.

Kataphatic descriptions of our county, of our values, and of who we are as individuals have pounded our ears for many months now, culminating in the political pageantry of the last few days.  Are we a nation that is harmed or strengthened by immigration? By free trade? By the Affordable Care Act? By actions to limit climate change? By our investments in the health and stability of other countries? By technological change? By the current composition of our military forces?  These are only a few of the categories in which we are asked to place ourselves.  These are only a few of the definitions we are asked to apply to ourselves.  And, like descriptions of God, they all seem to be both right and wrong.

On the march yesterday, I saw signs that lifted my spirit; and I saw others that made me cringe.  In President Trump’s flood of tweets I find much to deplore and some statements that give me hope.  Where and how do I find myself in this world where we are all expected to take sides?  How do I decide, as a citizen, what political actions to take, which efforts to endorse and which to oppose?

For me, this is where the apophatic tradition asserts its value.  It is in wordless prayer, it is in a contemplative and restorative silent listening, that I contact again my deepest self – that self that is most connected to God.  Like God, in whose image I am created, I am too complex to be defined by a word or a slogan, by a movement or a political party.  But also like God, my words, my thoughts, and my actions and inactions have consequences; to declare myself above or beyond politics is to deny and ignore those consequences.  It is in that listening prayer that I find some answers for my political self.  I will march; I will not shout “Dump Trump.”   I will urge my members of Congress to fund the Affordable Care Act; I do not have a clear position on free trade.  I want our efforts to limit climate change to include assistance for the poor and middle class who may be financially harmed.

In the bible study class we agreed that we needed a tradition “sandwich,” and I find myself relying on that now.  Being human, I take in ideas and possibilities using words; and on the other side, I require words to insert pieces of myself back into the public discussion – as I am doing here.  But in the center, the “meat” of the sandwich, I am reduced to silence – the silence of awe and confusion, of worry and dreams, of searching and listening – until some small piece of what I hope is God-given clarity emerges.

I need a lot of that silence these days.  I hope you can find it, too.

Dorothy Muller is a Chaplain at the Bedford Hills Correctional Facility and a Parish Associate at Bedford Presbyterian Church.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , | 1 Comment

Jesus Is Not An Enabler

From the very beginning of Jesus’ ministry we learn a very troubling lesson:
Our messiah is not an enabler.
You see Jesus is not here to do anything for us…
He is here to empower us to go out into the world to do the work of God.

Throughout all the gospels we see Jesus insisting over and over again that the power to heal he world does not reside solely in Jesus.  He sent out his disciples to heal in his name.  He sent the Holy Spirit to empower us…to go…to be the change we seek. Jesus came not to gather power for himself but to disperse it…to empower his followers and every person he encounters.

Jesus we learn from the Gospels was baptized and emerged from the water a new creation himself.  Suddenly the heavens were opened to him and he saw the Spirit of God descending like a dove and alighting on him. 17And a voice from heaven said, “This is my Son, the Beloved, with whom I am well pleased.” He believed the voice, and made his belovedness a part of him.  His belovedness made him unique but not special.  Not at least in the sense that his belovedness moved him to narcissism.  He never gave in to the temptations that followed his baptism by suggesting that he alone was the beloved and therefore he knew all the answers and alone would fix the world.

His “Ah Ha” moment went beyond the recognition of his unique relationship with God.  It extended to everyone’s unique relationship with God…”I am God’s beloved, son, yes…but so are you…you are God’s beloved daughter…you are God’s beloved son…with whom God is well pleased…”

Such an understanding, is at once healing and terrifying.
It is tempting to desire a messiah, a pastor, a parent, political leader, who will do it for us…Yet every baptized Christian is called to be the beloved servant…a dispenser if you would, of God’s unending generous blessing upon all creation.  We are to be as deeply immersed in the world as Jesus is…called to love and empower it.

I have signed up recently for a daily devotion from Sojourners Magazine called the Verse and Voice.  Each day into my inbox comes a Scripture Verse, a short reflection, quote and a prayer.  A recent quote was from the late Gwen Ifill:
“Real change comes from the people who make up their minds that if they see something, they will do something.”

The power to heal the world is something Jesus, from the beginning of his ministry on the banks of the Jordon River, intended to share with his followers.  When you see something I could imagine Jesus saying…do something…
Don’t expect me to do it for you…

Jesus was not an enabler.
Jesus was an empowerer.
May we remember our own baptism, the vows we took, the promises made to us and the promises we made.  May we embrace our belovedness and go out to empower others to embrace there own.

Angela Maddalone is the pastor at Palisades Presbyterian Church in Palisades, NY.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , | 1 Comment


2017 is the Year of the Rooster.
The Chinese have zodiac signs that follow a 12-year cycle featuring a specific animal each year.  The
rooster prompts an image of crowing and the cry to wake up and get to work!  Those who are born in the Year of the Rooster are perceived as being honest, intelligent, personable, independent and ambitious.  Myriad beliefs are associated with the tradition.

There is a bit of wistfulness that Christians do not dedicate each year with a singular focus.  Imagine the impact on our lives if this were The Year of Reverence!  

Our year would begin with an acknowledgement of our smallness.  We are not God.  We simply are a unique soul created and claimed by God.  Because of our smallness, we live humbly in relationship with the One who is greater than we.  Reverence is a response to this feeling of humility.  

Reverence involves the elements of worship, prayer, and the reading and interpretation of Scripture.  Reverence also includes awe, respect, discernment, shame and outrage.

Awe and Respect — We know what it is to experience awe in the presence of something greater than our imagining or ability: the Hudson River, Handel’s Messiah, St. Patrick’s Cathedral, the channeling of electricity, a computer that fits in the palm of our hand, a heart removed from one body and transplanted in another.  When we are reverent, we respect that which creates this sense of awe.

Discernment — Paul Woodruff, a humanities professor at the University of Texas in Austin, suggests that there is a reverent response to that which is not transcendent, when we are “in the presence of something base.”  For example, “the most reverent response to a tyrant . . . is to mock him.”  Reverence compels a response, even though the response may be disconcerting.

Shame and Outrage — Shame provides perspective.  There is conduct that is unacceptable.  There are moments when outrage is reverent.  A father once shared with me his reaction when he entered a room and found his grade-school son being choked by his friend.  The father grabbed his house guest and threatened his life.  “Don’t you ever touch my son again or I will kill you!”  The father’s outrage was because of his reverence for his son’s life.

Reverence is not merely calm and deferential.  Reverence requires a response when God’s creation is threatened.  

Laurie A. McNeill is a member of Hudson River Presbytery and she serves as a Teaching Elder in Highland and Marlboro, New York.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , | 1 Comment


To tell the truth, I am not one who is big on New Years.
Either the celebration or making resolutions.
Maybe because New Year’s always seems to come so quickly after Christmas and most years (including this one!) I am still trying to have my energy catch up with the calendar.
But here we are in the opening days of 2017.
A day which we have now, but never again.
Maybe it is a day for us to recognize the new year and to consider resolutions for the year ahead. Resolutions not about diet or exercise or spending more time with family and friends, but given the reality of the times in which we live, resolutions about what it means to be a Christian. A person of faith. A person called by God to be the salt of the earth and the light of the world; to treat others the way you would like to be treated; to be called blessed because you are known to be a peacemaker or because you hunger and thirst for righteousness or because you are merciful.

A blog to which I subscribe had this title on yesterday’s post:
Extraordinary Times Call for Extraordinary Churches.
These are churches willing to look outward more than they look inward and to see others as neighbors and who are willing to ask what they can do to heal a world too often broken by hatred and fear and prejudice and violence. Maybe we could or should replace the word church with the word Christian or the words People of Faith.
Whatever word or words we chose, they include you and me.

So, what about this as a place we might start.
We use this Affirmation of Faith each time we celebrate a baptism.
We are not alone.  We live in God’s world.  We believe in God who has created and who is creating; who is made known to us in the life and ministry of Jesus; and who works in us and in others through the Spirit.  We place our trust in God.  God calls us to be the Church; to celebrate God’s presence; to love and serve others; to seek justice and to resist evil.  In life, in death, in life beyond death, God is with us.  Thanks be to God.

Here is what I am going to ask you to do.
Below is a series of questions.
Read through them.
Pick two or three (or more if you would like) which tug at you in some way. And then write down what what you hope to do to deepen that part of your life of faith.
Here are several guidelines.
Be specific. Maybe something like I am going to read one book related to my faith or values.
Be realistic. You are not going to read the entire Bible each month.
Risk something new. None of us is who or where God calls us to be.

When you are finished, put what you wrote some place where you will see it.
Read through what you wrote at least once a week.
Jot down notes about what you are experiencing and learning and where and how God is tugging at your life.

Here are the questions:

  • What would you like to do in order to better see and experience and name those places where God is still creating? In your life? In the world around us?
  • What would you like to do in order to better understand the life and ministry of Jesus and what his example means for your life and how you live?
  • How might you deepen your trust in God or better understand what that means for your life?
  • How might you better notice and name and celebrate God’s presence in your life and our world?
  • How might you better love and serve others?
  • How might you seek justice and resist evil?

Paul Alcorn is the Pastor of Bedford Presbyterian Church in Bedford Village, NY.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , | 1 Comment



“Of course it is trouble, it wouldn’t be Christmas if it were not a lot of trouble.”                                               Garrison Keillor

“I will honor Christmas in my heart, and try to keep it all the year.”                                                                   Ebenezer Scrooge

I love Christmas.  It is by far my favorite holiday. So, since I was in London before Christmas last year I made a point of visiting the Charles Dickens museum.  It is housed in one of his family homes in London.  It was nicely decorated for Christmas.  And I could almost conjure the spirit of the man who had given us so many wonderful books and A Christmas Carol.  It may be surprising but A Christmas Carol was written in rather challenging and troubling times for Charles Dickens. Dickens had published many books by 1843 but at the time his popularity seemed to be waning.  If he couldn’t sell his books he could never maintain his family of four, soon to be five, in the way they had enjoyed.  Also, by mid-19th century England was in the midst of a social transformation because of the Industrial Revolution. The difference between rich and poor was ever growing.  And yet it seemed to Dickens that there was very little concern for the plight of the poor.  This troubled Dickens very much.  He was particularly aware of the suffering of the children.  Poor and orphaned children were often put to work at an early age because they did not have to be paid much.  Dickens was so distraught about it that he visited the mines in Cornwall where many children worked.  He also visited poorer parts of London where children were put to work in factories.  So incensed was he that he put to writing a protest pamphlet about the conditions of the poor in London.  But in the midst of writing it he had a different idea.  What was needed was a change of heart among those taking advantage. He decided to write a story about the careless greed he saw all around him.  He used his favorite holiday for the setting.

That is the essence of Christmas for me.  Many people bemoan the business of the season and all the burdens that go with it.  However, it seems to me that on some level this is what we are called to.  It does not take much reading of this world to realize that these are troubled times.  It is hard to not be persuaded by the many voices that proclaim the end.  The truth is that the world is always been so troubled.  In the face of all this God gives us a sweet little story about the perseverance of faith, the eternal nature of love, and unending hope. And God says it is enough if we respond in love, hope and faith.  It may not seem like much and it is not unless we respond.  Christmas can be a gaudy overproduction or it can be the sweetest of commitments to make this life worth living.  So I go to great trouble to make and celebrate Christmas but it can’t end there.  As Scrooge says in the end it is a matter of living up to the message of Christmas all the year long.  Dickens knew that our very lives can be transformed by love and hope and faith and so we must be so changed and so transform this troubled world around us.  Merry Christmas!

Tim Ives is a therapist who has a special interest in teens and families.  His office is in Bedford Hills. He is also a Presbyterian Minister at Scarborough Presbyterian Church.  He is married and  has two young adult children.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment